What is WRONG with these People?

The embarrassments just keep coming, and the continued descent into self-parody of a once-rational political party is painful to watch. It seems that every day brings a new “WTF moment,” another occasion to shake one’s head and contemplate the GOP’s penchant for self-destruction.

A couple of days ago, the U.S. Senate failed to ratify a United Nations treaty on the rights of the disabled–a treaty modeled after the Americans with Disabilities Act. The Treaty would not have required a single change to current U.S. law; its ratification was, in a sense, a formality, intended to bring the rest of the member nations up to the standard set by the United States. Bob Dole came in his wheelchair to urge Republican Senators to ratify it. Dick Lugar and John McCain were among the eight GOP “defectors” who joined all of the Democratic Senators voting for ratification.

According to media reports, ultra-conservatives associated with the Tea Party, led by former Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum, opposed the treaty on the grounds that it threatened U.S. sovereignty and parental rights. Santorum, who has a daughter with special needs, argued that the treaty would effectively put the United States under international law and give the U.N. discretion over decisions about how special needs children are educated.

This, of course, is nonsense–part and parcel of the paranoia that characterizes the Right’s frantic rejection of anything connected to the United Nations and increasingly, Europe. EvenĀ Bob Dole and Dick Lugar couldn’t shame them--but then, how do you shame crazy? So–add the disabled to the growing group of constituencies–women, immigrants, gays, young people–that the party has infuriated.

Washington is hardly the only habitat of the legislative loon, of course. Here in Indiana, we breed dozens of them.

The Northwest Indiana Times captured a quintessential example, under a headline that deserves some sort of prize: “Indiana Senator’s Plan to Teach Creationism Evolves.”

State Senator Denise Kruse has sponsored some of the Senate’s most constitutionally-suspect measures. Most recently, he’s been trying to pass legislation that would require the teaching of creationism in public school classrooms. Last session, his measure passed the (overwhelmingly Republican) Senate, but House Speaker Brian Bosma killed it in the House. Bosma is a lawyer, and obviously is aware that the courts have settled this debate, holding that creationism is religion, not science, and cannot be taught as science.

Kruse told the Times that he would not submit a similar bill this time. No, he said, he “wants to empower students to challenge their teachers” and “to make sure what is being taught is true.” He will sponsor a bill require teachers to justify and support their lessons.

I don’t know what Kruse thinks happens in a classroom. Given his public pronouncements, it’s fair to assume he hasn’t been in many. But I can’t imagine a classroom where students don’t challenge their teachers, or a classroom where teachers aren’t absolutely ecstatic when they can share with students the evidence and research underlying the substance of their subject-matter. Does he think students come into the classroom for indoctrination sessions? That teachers hypnotize children, or pour pre-packaged lessons into the tops of their heads?

Since conspiracy theories seem to be the order of the day, here’s mine: someone is putting hallucinogenic substances in the food of Republican elected officials. And baby, those substances are strong.

5 Comments

  1. I felt uncomfortably sad watching Bob Dole, injured vet, on the floor with an imminently good idea (UN Disabilities Treaty) burning in flames on the alter of ideological idiocy. Kinda made me want to run down to DC with my big iron and smooth some of the sphincter wrinkles out of the foreheads of the goober wing of the Senate Republicans. About 130 nations signed so I suppose they will move forward without US but do we really have to thumb our nose at the rest of the world at every turn? How shortsighted.

  2. I felt uncomfortably sad watching Bob Dole, injured vet, on the floor with an imminently good idea (UN Disabilities Treaty) burning in flames on the alter of ideological idiocy. Kinda made me want to run down to DC with my big iron and smooth some of the sphincter wrinkles out of the foreheads of the goober wing of the Senate Republicans. About 130 nations signed so I suppose they will move forward without US but do we really have to thumb our nose at the rest of the world at every turn? How shortsighted.

    However, even they show a pattern of twisted intelligence. Obstruction as strategy captured 47% of the American voters this Presidential season.

    Mr. Kruse shows a pattern of such obstreperous blind faith un-encumbered by serious thought that his fellows become embarrassed while letting his leadership take the hit.

  3. They walk among us. Dan Coats is in the pack. Apparently, he thinks he is more informed than Dick Lugar.

  4. Actually, although I recognise that Kruse’s motivation for such a bill is doubtless unforgiveable, I would personally have *killed* for legal language like that to back me up when I was in public school. I can easily imagine just such a nightmare classroom because I was in all too many of them – although, unlike what Kruse has in mind, the challenges I would have made would have been based in facts. I can still clearly remember the middle-school history teacher who insisted that “manifest” meant “to grow”, and “manifest destiny” was thus “destiny to grow”. Even though I knew better, I didn’t say anything because I’d already been punished enough for doing so before. Nor was that the last time.

Comments are closed.